EditionININUSUKGCCEnglishEnglishहिन्दीमराठीಕನ್ನಡதமிழ்বাংলাമലയാളംతెలుగుગુજરાતીWeatherSign InTOIToday's ePaperLiveNewsCity Newsahmedabad NewsFlat tyre can’t fly as force majeure defence for airlineTrendingKolkata MurderDelhi Building CollapseUP MurderBengaluru AccidentPM ModiBengaluru MurderKolkata MurderDelhi Building CollapseUP MurderBengaluru AccidentPM ModiBengaluru MurderKolkata MurderDelhi Building CollapseUP MurderBengaluru AccidentPM ModiBengaluru MurderFlat tyre can’t fly as force majeure defence for airlineSaeed Khan / Nov 09, 2026, 17:40 ISTCommentsShareAaText SizeSmallMediumLargePrint 'Can’t escape liability’ Ahmedabad: An airline cannot cite a flat tyre as force majeure to escape liability for cancelling a flight, particularly when the aircraft was grounded because of inadequate fleet management, the Gujarat State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has ruled.
The court upheld compensation for travellers whose flight was cancelled and who were not informed.The case involved Kamlesh Jani, who booked two tickets on flight VA-702 of Ventura Air Connect Ltd scheduled on Oct 2, 2023, from Amreli to Surat. When he reached the airport from his native town Khambha, he found out that the flight was cancelled and he received an intimation email after the scheduled departure time. He entered into heated arguments with the ground staff.
What happened
Miffed with the blacklisting, Jani sued the airline before Amreli District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, which directed the airline to pay Rs 6,000 towards his to-and-fro taxi expenses, Rs 50,000 for mental agony and harassment, and Rs 3,000 towards litigation costs.
The detail
It also ordered the airline to remove his name from its blacklist. The airline appealed before the state commission against the compensation order and argued that its aircraft had developed a flat tyre and all flights had to be cancelled in accordance with aviation safety norms.
The wider picture
It also contended that the ticket fare had been refunded and the passenger had failed to establish harassment. Rejecting the force majeure defence, the commission observed that the airline operated three aircraft, of which two were already under maintenance, leaving its entire day’s operations dependent on a single aircraft. It said, “The sole operational aircraft should develop a flat tyre is not an act of God but a foreseeable consequence of the opponent having left itself no margin for contingency.
What comes next
We find no merit in the opponent’s characterisation of the cancellation as force majeure, and we hold that the deflation of the tyre occurring as it did in the context of two-thirds of the opponent’s fleet already being out of service, reflects a lapse in maintenance and fleet management attributable squarely to the opponent and constitutes deficiency in service. You Can Also Check: Gold Rate in Ahmedabad | Silver Rate in Ahmedabad | Bank Holidays in Ahmedabad | Public Holidays in Ahmedabad | Ahmedabad AQI | Weather in Ahmedabad | Petrol Price in Ahmedabad | Diesel Price in Ahmedabad | CNG Price in Ahmedabad | LPG Price in AhmedabadStay updated with the latest Ahmedabad news.
Additional context
He reports on all the courts in the city and legal issues.
Analysis
He occasionally reports on cultural and social issues as well. End of ArticleFollow Us On Social MediaVideosPhotostoriesHot PicksDelhi AQINew York CourtJim CarreyCBSE Date Sheet 2027North Carolina StudentSonia GandhiDundee Transport ManagerGreenpeace UKJason KelceFortnite Treasure HourTop TrendingBronny JamesTaylor SwiftJoe burrowTravis Kelce InjuryStephen Curry WifeRashee RiceFloyd MayweatherPM ModiUP MurderBhind historic house incidentTired of too many ads? go ad free nowTrending StoriesIn AhmedabadIn CityAmit Shah inaugurates 4-km Iskcon-Sanand elevated corridor in AhmedabadNew Year, new hope: Four Great Indian Bustard chicks to arrive in Gujarat from RajasthanSeized ‘mawa’ tested as barfi; labelling error forces AMC to book traders for the lighter offence of misbrandingDrunk driver found in parked SUV near GU Metro stationAhmedabad: From first bill to pehla hisaab, traders keep New Year traditions aliveDiwali festivities lead to 13% spike in emergencies in Ahmedabad, reveals EMRI 108 dataAir, noise pollution prompt cops to vacate riverfrontSSSlithery surprise: Krait’s 2am handbag hideout sparks scare at Gandhinagar hospital; roving reptile had slid down the parking ramp and disappeared among five bags kept in the basementAhmedabad says Saal Mubarak, welcomes Vikram Samvat 2083Ahmedabad: Diwali cracker row turns violent; resident fires in air to disperse mob‘Sound of sickles was louder than crackers in Tamil Nadu on Diwali day’: Opposition slams TVK govt over series of murders‘Pollution due to your corruption’: Minister Kapil Mishra accuses Kejriwal of planning anti-Diwali campaign; alleges paid celebrities to target Hindus festivalNo family gathering?
Reactions
Singles in Bengaluru find their own spark this Diwali75-year-old man burnt to death in house fire in Lucknow; mosquito-repellent incense stick suspectedDreams bought on credit, lives lost to debt: The human cost of borrowingKarnataka stands firm on ethanol row: Minister Rizwan Arshad says oil companies blended up to 31. 2% in petrol, demands choice of E10, E20, E30 and pure petrol for consumers20 cartons of suspected beef seized at Delhi's Hazrat Nizamuddin railway stationRape-murder accused gunned down in West Bengal; 4th encounter since BJP came to powerLucknow driver dies by suicide after alleging harassment by 2 women, encounter threat by police; records 6 videos before jumping in front of trainTamil Nadu man alleges TVK MLA assaulted him over civic grievances, later denies claim in videoTired of too many ads? go ad free nowDaily PuzzlesConnectThe Perfect TracePlay Now Loop The LoopPuzzle CircuitPlay Now Daily CrosswordSpecial puzzlePlay Now Explore More PuzzlesExplore Every CornerAcross The GlobeTata MotorsJason KelceKolkata Techie MurderAlice HuangShiloh AttounQueen ElizabethRichard Phillip EckertKolkata BriyaniTrump Washington Golf CourseMary RothJacob MannTiger WoodsTom BradyJoe BurrowSunil GavaskarTravis Kelce Financial CareerRachel ApaBrittany MahomesIndia Test MatchPatrick MahomesKansas City ChiefsCooper KuppUS Iran WarPakistan Vs Sri Lanka Match ScoreTravis kelceNvidia SharesHSBCKarnataka PUC ExamArchaeologist Miles RussellAir CanadaAbout usCreate Your Own AdTerms of Use and Grievance Redressal Policy Privacy policyAdvertise with usRSSNewsletterFeedbackePaperContact UsEditorial PolicyLiving and EntertainmentCricbuzzLifestyleNewspaper SubscriptionFood NewsTVTimes PrimeTravel DestinationsWhats HotETimesTimes PetsServicesBreaking NewsTimes MobileGadgets NowCity NewsWork with UsColombiaTOI AutoLuxury TOI HomesTOI Home & DecorEcopreneurWellnessAIQHot on the WebR J MittesTyson NaiduKajal AggarwalRamayana ReviewLuke IoannouRanbir KapoorRamayana CollectionIsha KoppikarParvathy ThiruvothuDipika ChikhliaMookuthi Amman Box Office CollectionShruti HaasanIneyaSimon TikhmanTaylor SwiftVijayBaby NamesBarbra StreisandScene Movie CollectionJailer 2 CollectionNaga ChaitanyaSalman KhanVivek OberoiSurekha VaniStephen KingNitesh TiwariSaba Ali KhanNamit MalhotraDrishyam 3 Box Office CollectionHoroscope TodayRailways CompensationDRDO Pralay MissileHyundai Grand i10Burmese PythonsSpinning Black HolesDinosaur FossilsSpanish Copper MineCoastal Defence SystemDead Sea Scrolls3800 Year Old Woman LetterPoland Vampire BurialCaptions For Instagram PostsTrending TopicsUP Car AccidentBhopal Fire TragedyChhattisgarh MurderMumbai FireKolkata Noise PollutionDelhi PollutionBhopal FireDelhi Firecracker AccidentAmol DixitDK ShivakumarBengaluru MurderTamil Nadu Firecracker InjuryMumbai AQIParth PawarPapia AdhikariDelhi AQIKevin PatelKarnataka DroughtMP Firecracker InjuriesPune Garbage DepotMysuru ProtestManisha Salat DeathBengaluru Serial MurdersAhmedabad AssaultDelhi Air PollutionSamsung South KoreaDonald TrumpStock Market TodayRupee Exchange RateSheikh HasinaDave WehnerDonald HarrisonTim CookSam AltmanApple Google DonationsJeff BezosUber AI AgentsCanada Doorbell CamerasOpenAI GPT-6 CyberSergey BrinZohran MamdaniPopular CategoriesHeadlinesSports NewsBusiness NewsIndia NewsWorld NewsInternational SportsHealthBreaking NewsTravelAstrologyDeorhiTOI Young LeadersTOI Home Decor AwardsPower Creator Awards 2026The Times of India EcopreneurGold Rate TodayWeather TodaySilver Price TodayDelhi Weather TodayPetrol Price TodayDiesel Price TodayCNG Price TodayLPG Price TodayPetrol Price MumbaiFIFA 2026Is Bank Open TodayFIFA 2026 ScheduleIs Bank Open TomorrowPublic Holidays in JuneBank Holidays in JuneTrending VideosGerman Giants Cut Jobs at Home: Can India Take Germany's Engineering Crown?
Developments
| The Great ReversalChina Denies Spy Links To NVIDIA Boss Jensen Huang's Affair Amid Board Probe; ‘Baseless Smear'‘I Cheated’ NVIDIA Boss Admits; But ‘honourable’ For Trump: Epstein to Elon, Trump's Circle Of SinRussell Brand's Darkest Hour; Convictions Put Comedian's Future In DoubtNetanyahu Turns To Putin After Trump Fallout?
Local impactFollow how this story develops and what it means for you.
Source: Flat tyre can’t fly as force majeure defence for airline (timesofindia.indiatimes.com) · Nov 9, 2026
What to do next
- Read more about this topic on LYVGO.
- See related stories from the same desk.
- Follow this developing story for the latest updates.











































Comments